When I send message Outbox shows 1 message pending but there is no message to be seen in folder, after sending message arrives at destination but no message in sent folder either in K9 or webmail. However if I send from PC message shows in K9 and webmail This is with 5.802 upload sent messages is ticked in setting
1 Like
Thatās a small display bug and shouldnāt be a problem. The side bar counts are not updated after sending.
Check your folder settings. Maybe the wrong folder is selected for saving the messages in. Settings Ā» Account Ā» Folders.
Thanks, the setting for Sent folder was the default Automatic, I changed this to Sent and it seems to be working OK now.
maybe it is better if the app, during installing, sets directly āSent folderā to āSent messagesā
1 Like
I 100% endorse this suggestion - after installing the Android app it took me a while to realise that sent items were not automatically being saved to a Sent folder - even though Iād checked and rechecked the āUpload sent messagesā option in Settings.
When I saw āAutomaticā next to a folder name in Settings / Folders I foolishly imagined it would default to āSent messagesā, āSent itemsā or some such - but, no, sent messages are silently deleted from the Outbox!
Please could this default be changed? Or at least warned about.
Apart from that - a nice little client!
1 Like
Using the latest version of the K-9 app, I have lost plenty of sent messages because, despite my checking āupload sent messagesā, the sent message folder was set to Automatic / NONE. Actually, all of the folders on the two IMAP work accounts were automatically set to Automatic / NONE, basically to dev/null, incredible.
This app should at least warn the user that the automatic selection of folders did not go through and that everything is basically moved to /dev/null. This choice of NONE is actually quite hard to understand, indeed K-9 is the only client I have ever used that makes this choice, letting you lose data.
2 Likes
If you have a āsmartā server, you might be lucky. Some servers put mail without a target into a ālost and foundā or ārecovered itemsā folder. E.g., my server puts any mail that encounters an error into ālost and foundā, just in case it was downloaded or uploaded incompletely, etc.
You can check whether your server has such capabilities either through a Webmailer with ālost and foundā support (e.g. Roundcube) or a CLI mailer such as mutt.
Thank you. I tried to recover them, but my servers are not āsmartā. But the problem here is that K-9 should be smarter, not the servers.
Personally, since I use plenty of devices, with different locales and languages, I do not care about folder names. Every time I tried to āfixā them and use the same folder per ātypeā, e.g. placing all the sent messages in āSentā instead of the various āSentā, āSent messagesā, āMessaggi inviatiā, āPosta inviataā, etc. I ended up missing at least one of them.
So I know that my sent messages can be in any one of M folders corresponding to sent mail. But with K-9 I discovered that they can even be in no folders at all. I am not saying that K-9 should change its way of using Automatic/NONE, but that K-9 should WARN the user that messages will be thrown away in the void when it decides to use NONE.
2 Likes
Old thread I know but as a new K-9 user I experienced this issue and would like to thank everyone for pointing me to the fix.
So, this is fixed for you by following thr sugestions mentioned above?
What a sad let-down - otherwise good software with a glaring pitfall.
Sure, I can read up and find out that when I have āUpload messages to Sent folder after sendingā ticked, then the software assumes that I will want this to go nowhere (because the default folder isnāt in fact the Sent folder but no folder at all). But do you know what? I have better uses for time. I trust software to behave reasonably and expect that if I behave sensibly, I should get a sensible result.
Come on people, this isnāt a reasonable way for software to behave. It is a (minor) bug, but it is a pitfall that will mean that I donāt recommend K-9 to others - if you are OK to leave this hidden pitfall unfixed, what other dangers are there still lurking that you also feel are OK to leave?
2 Likes
This is too bad. I am a longtime Thunderbird fan - pretty much since launch - and I recently moved back to K9 Mail on the assumption that the integration of the systems would have made the product pretty robust by now.
But I just discovered the āAutomatic(none)ā problem. Seriously? LIke others in this forum I have lost a number of emails simply because I sent them from the app.
Iām going back to Bluemail - sorry.