Email forwarded without attachments when the forwarded message is not fully downloaded

Hi,

When I forward a mail with attachments that are not yet downloaded, the mail recipient recieves the mail without attachments (unexpected). However, when I first download the attachments by clicking the “download the full message” button at the message bottom, then forward the mail, the email recipient recieves the mail with all attachments (expected).

Is it a bug?

As a workaround, I may configure the mail account to set the mail retrieval max size to “any Size”, but thats not very practical.

Thanks in avance.

K9 mail version : 5.806
Android version : 11

1 Like

Yes, I can reproduce it. I would see it as a bug, as I would expect a message box telling you that you have not yet fully downloaded it when you try to forward a not fully downloaded mail.

2 Likes

This problem has existed for a long time, also in old versions of the app.

This bug is always there on version 6.4 on Android 13.
It’s a problem because very often you just want to share attachments without explicitly download each of them manually.
They should be automatically downloaded for the forwarding and remove justafter to be send withoout them.
Or at leat a mssage should inform user that attachments had not been downloaded and they won’t b send with the message

2 Likes

As a new user i trapped into this issue which gave me some headache, there should at least be a notice, and we have already 2024.

@cketti
Just wondering whether this bug will be resolved in the near future…

Unfortunately I also have the same problem.
Is this bug expected to be fixed in the near future?

Would be nice to receive an update soon, which features any if the above mentioned solutions.

@dev team: can you please give us a timeline on that, or just inform about wether it is something you’re working on?

All the best
Zoli

@cketti
Still wondering whether this bug will be resolved in the near future…

This is not a high priority issue because there’s an easy workaround. Tap the “Download complete message” button before forwarding the message.

1 Like

Yes, but should not be complicated to be fixed. At least a warning on forward that mail is not fully downloaded. That would help a lot

Pull requests are welcome :smiley:

1 Like

Isn’t there such a warning already? I’m sure I saw it a week or two ago. Or was I dreaming?

I agree; wouldn’t it just entail a simple command of ‘download the entire message to be forwarded’?

It’s not that easy. Many users on limited data plans have set download limits. If K-9 were to silently download messages to be forwarded, these plan limits may be exceeded, incurring additional costs.

Also, just downloading the body is insufficient. All attachments must also be downloaded in order to forward the entire email.

I would suggest to only automatically download messages for forward if no limits are set. If the user has defined download limits, a warning must be displayed before downloading the message for forwarding.

K-9 displays a pop-up warning for me, if I try to forward a message with attachments that have not been downloaded.

I’m on 6.904

1 Like